Tuesday, September 30, 2014

So it came up in conversation....

as part of that conversation, the statement was made to me that "You don't like cops".

I was, to be honest, a bit surprised...."But look at what you post!", they said.

For the record:
I neither like nor dislike cops. I think that they do a really tough job, and some of it is dealing with terribly nasty and ugly people. And for those who DO THEIR JOB WELL (which, for the record, I believe is a majority of cops) I have a great deal of respect.

However, I am very critical of men and women who have life or death powers, who have arrest powers, who can literally shoot you or me and be excused for their actions, who do their job poorly, or who have a bad attitude about those citizens (note: Cops too are citizens) whom they police. I dislike and am critical about policemen (and women, but from this point I will use the all encompassing "Policemen" as representing all genders) who are abusive of the powers they are granted as EMPLOYEES of our society. They are not lords over the rest of us, nor should they be given special treatment just because they are police. In fact, I strongly believe that they should be held to a HIGHER standard of behavior simply because of the job they do and the powers that they are given. Further, should they break laws, they should be punished to a greater level that those other citizens who they police...simply because they have violated the trust we as a society place in them.

I believe that too many policemen are unsuited for the job, being psychologically unable to wield the power they have in a benign manner. Too many are bullies, either as their normal psychological profile or from just plain job fatigue. Either way, cops shouldn't be, or act like, bullies. I know they train cops today that "If you aren't in control, you are under control", but they don't have to act like assholes in every interaction.

Here is a bit of advice for cops:

I believe that respect is earned, and that unless all police hold each other to a high standard (rather than make excuses for their fellow officers' bad behavior, as happens so often) that the respect that police officers need and want will never be forthcoming. Also, respect begets respect, and if you knock on a door or come to a car and act like an arrogant ass, you'll be treated like one more often than not. (and yes, it does work both ways, I understand that...but clamping down hard in every interaction with normal citizens just makes us mad, does not generate fear, and especially does not generate respect) Police men and women need to police their own ranks strenuously FIRST, with as much (if not more) vigor than they do the rest of the society they watch. How I interact with the next cop will likely be a result of how my previous interactions with police went.

Policemen are peace officers....not soldiers. Yes, there are situations which require that they act like soldiers, but not everyday, and not in every encounter. Wanna be treated with respect? Dress like a cop, not door-kicker in a place like Kabul or Falujah. Yes, wear protective gear, but DON"T LOOK LIKE A SOLDIER! LOOK LIKE A COP. Dump the Tactical Tommy look, especially the black uniform with the silver badges.... especially when you are on patrol.  Everyone you meet isn't planning on killing you. Yes, you need to be careful, but.......

If you are so afraid that each stop you make is going to result in your death that you treat each and every traffic stop as if there were guns poking out of the car windows....then you need to find another profession. Yes, being a cop is dangerous, and you should be careful...and believe it or not, I too want you to come home after every shift to you family safe and sound....but really. Approaching each stop and every citizen you interact with with fear and treating them as if they each were a killer like John Dillinger is both insulting to us and bit frightening as well. Relax a bit. We aren't all recently escaped from prison. If you are that afraid, then find another job. Seriously.

Remember, the people you interact with aren't all criminals.... don't treat everyone you meet like that 3rd time loser you saw yesterday. We aren't all on drugs, aren't all thieves, and we aren't all recently paroled. Yes, I realize that many of the folks you interact with are like that, but not all of us are. Some of us haven't committed any crimes. Threatening to "run my sheet" just makes me angry, or amused, depending, as I have no "sheet". Treating me as if I were recently paroled just makes me angry. Threatening me with arrest because I am not compliant enough makes me angry enough to make a complaint.

Remember that pesky Constitution. Yes, it gets in your way sometimes. But it is what stands between US and being a Banana Republic. Respect it. Deal with the limitations if puts upon you and your job. If you can't accept that, or find it too inconvenient and are willing to ignore it, then you are in the wrong profession. 

Be ethical in how you treat people. Yes, I understand that you are busy, and frustrated and tired. I understand that it has been a long week....and that you pulled a double...Still. Treat us well. We are, after all, the folks you chose to serve. Be nice and respectful and professional. It will help with some of us. Don't cut corners. Here is a hint: If you want us to do something, explain why, if possible. Don't bark orders. I don't work for you and am not under your power.  Ask.  Politely.  You'll find that most of us will cooperate. You can always go to being an asshole, but it is hard to back up from that once you've gone there. Try nice first...Remember, we aren't subject to your orders.

Pay attention to the above, and for those of us that aren't bad guys or troublemakers, you'll have a more pleasant interaction, as will we. Less stress for both of us. More respect for you.

Try it. You'll be pleasantly surprised most of the time.


Murphy's Law said...

The problem that I see with your posts is that you create a fantasy "bully cop" to rail against and act as if that fictitious one is representative of every real police officer out there today, and that's not the case. Sure, given all of the news crawlers out there today, it's not hard to find the isolated story of one cop somewhere in the world being overly aggressive, or a picture of a few more wearing BDUs for some reason, but you stretch it into an assertion that they ALL do this all the time. It's no more fair or accurate than the caricature that the Left has of us gun owners as a bunch of ignorant hicks who just want to use our CCWs and assault rifles to kill people, particularly minorities. Now when they say stuff like that, we rightfully object because it's not true, but you're doing the same thing here about police officers.

And you talk about police training, but the fact of that is that today, unlike any other time in history, police training pushes constitutional and civil rights, de-escalation techniques in lieu of force, and less lethal alternatives to deadly force. Today's rookie cops are more kindly and gentle as a whole than they've ever been and you're railing against something that really doesn't exist except in internet anecdotes.

Now if the police officers that you encounter always tend to treat you as if you're a criminal, I have to ask how you're acting towards them to put them on that footing, because most cops, even today's milk-toast young cops, are pretty good at reading people and like anyone else, they give back what they get. If you're polite and respectful towards them from the get-go, I have a hard time accepting that every one that you meet becomes a domineering bully just for the hell of it.

Moe said...

Right Murphy,

It's the "civilians" causing the trouble.

Mostly cops act like pricks; everybody knows that.


Murphy's Law said...

No, Moe, "everybody" doesn't know that, because it's not true. I've seen your posts here and your bias against police officers is pretty apparent. Maybe you should become one and then you can show the rest of them and us how it's supposed to be done, eh?

B said...

Murphy...You need to reread....with AN ATTEMPT AT COMPREHENSION THIS TIME.

I don't indict all cops. In fact, I point out that MOST do a good job.

And while you may have great interactions with police (and, for the most part, so do I) there are some officers (and some citizens as well) who don't do a good job of interacting with others. Sadly, this reflects on all other cops.

Moe said...

You're right "everybody"doesn't know that. A large segment of the population is unknowing, poorly informed or just plain ignorant.

A bias against police officers? What you left out of that statement was the words "abusive/militarized."